Left and Leaving vs. Hot Fuss

I thought I had put Hot Fuss on the list.  I went back and reviewed and saw that it didn't make the cut for me... but it was in the running.  There are some Killers songs that are great.  So it is with great sadness that I report here that the entire album now sounds dated to me.  I -remember- liking it more that I do now.

SO... Left and Leaving?  Honestly, a little blah BUT better than my listening to the Killers.  It had a good quality that initially really appealed to me, but never had anything that stuck in my head.  Felt a little anonymous, even after repeated listenings.

Decision: Left and Leaving.